This homemade herb butter is versatile and easy to make with just a few simple steps. Plus, it’s a wonderful way to preserve your fresh herbs to enjoy all year long!
* * *
I don’t know about you, but where we live, summer ended pretty abruptly this year. One minute the sun was still shining, and BAM, rainstorms and thunder showers moved in and summer officially came to a very sudden, very sad end; The kind when you’re just not quite ready to say goodbye to a season yet because you don’t feel like you really got to enjoy it in all its glory.
That’s the thing about this homesteading life: summers seem to just fly by because we’re so busy gardening and harvesting that it’s hard to justify taking a moment to just sit back and enjoy it all.
Luckily we did squeeze in some camping this year and a few solid days at the beach and waterpark, but we really did spend most of the summer working. Between all of that gardening and preserving, launching a brand new website and a brand new magazine too, I feel like I spent most of the summer either in front of a computer, in the kitchen or with my nose just inches away from the dirt! And hey, it’s not such a bad way to spend a summer, but still, I’m not quite ready to say goodbye just yet!
Even so, the reality is that the rains came early this year, and now we’re scrambling to get the rest of our summer crops harvested and put up before they rot out there:(
But as much as the tomatoes and peppers really need my attention right now, I wanted to make sure to get a bunch of my fresh herbs preserved before it gets too cold. I’ve already dried a bunch and made some infusions, but I really wanted to preserve the taste and freshness of my summer herbs just as they are right now but to enjoy all winter long.
One great way to do this is by making your own herb butter, otherwise known as “compound butter,” which essentially just means butter mixed with other ingredients (in this case, fresh herbs:)
The great thing about making compound butter recipes with herbs from your garden is that you can use fresh herbs and preserve them at their peak, so that when it comes time to enjoy them, it’s almost as if you just cut them fresh from your herb garden! It can really take an otherwise simple recipe to the next level.
You can enjoy the finished herb butter in a variety of delicious dishes…from bread and biscuits to meat (think roasted chicken, turkey, or a perfectly cooked steak), to vegetables (carrots, potatoes or even mushrooms fried in herb butter… YUM!) We even like to roll our corn in herb butter when it’s fresh and soft in the summer time!
Then when ready to use, just slice off however much you need from the log of butter and allow it to come to room temperature.
Alright, now that you know how to make herb butter, here are my family’s three favourite recipes, along with some other suggested herb combinations.
Garlic & Chive Butter
A Classic! Use this garlic and chive butter on toasted garlic bread, whipped into mashed potatoes, or on top of baked potatoes or sweet potatoes.
- 1 cup salted room temperature butter
- ¼ cup finely chopped fresh garlic
- ½ cup chopped fresh chives
Garlic, Rosemary & Thyme Butter
The rosemary and thyme in this garlic herb compound butter is perfect rubbed all over a roast. Whether roast beef, roast chicken or roast turkey, you can’t go wrong basting with this.
- 1 cup salted room temperature butter
- ¼ cup finely chopped fresh garlic
- ¼ cup finely chopped fresh rosemary
- ¼ cup finely chopped fresh thyme
Mint, Parsley & Chive Butter
The combination of mint, parsley and chives in this compound butter will take you back to summer no matter what time of year you enjoy it. Add it to scrabbled eggs for, smear it on biscuits or roll your corn on the cob in it.
- 1 cup salted room temperature butter
- ¼ cup finely chopped fresh mint
- ¼ cup finely chopped fresh parsley
- ¼ cup finely chopped fresh chives
Other homemade herb butter flavour combinations
Here are some other flavour combinations that make good candidates for compound butter recipes…
- Basil & lemon zest
- Lavender & honey
- Rosemary & orange zest
- Sage, rosemary & garlic
- Parsley, chives & dill
- Basil, oregano, rosemary & thyme
You can also make single-herb compound butters to use in different ways. Try tarragon butter on chicken, sage butter on roast turkey, lemon balm butter on seafood or pasta, mint butter on roast lamb or rosemary butter on roast beef.
Whatever herb combinations you choose, be sure to add compound butter to your list of preserves this summer (before the summer’s gone for good!)
Of course, be sure to stock some dried herbs too, and add them to sauces, soups and stews throughout the winter months, or to infuse or enjoy as tea.
What about you? Have you made your own herb butter before? What’s your favourite combination of herbs? Let me know in the comments below!
Can I mix sage and rosemary with my mayo for chicken salad? Do those herbs work together or do they clash?
Those herbs go great together! They’re also both ingredients in poultry seasoning blends. -Ashley (Assistant)
Hi Anna, again, this question has nothing to do with compound butter. However, I need an answer about baking. Are you a baker of breads and/or a maker of yogurt?
I am using stevia as a sweetener in liquid refreshments. My question is this; can you use the bulk sweetener in making yogurt and baking breads. Thanks in advance
I am a baker/maker of both:) As for using Stevia, you should be able to use it in place of sugar in both bread and yogurt. For homemade yogurt, I don’t use any sugar/sweetener unless I’m looking to sweeten it afterward. In this case, you could of course use Stevie to sweeten to your liking. Here’s my recipe for homemade yogurt.
With bread, it depends on the bread, but most breads only call for a small amount of added sugar, or even none at all. I’m sure you could substitute sugar for Stevia or omit it altogether in most recipes and you would probably be fine. The only time I know you really should use real sugar is when making a ferment like kombucha. Even for sourdough starter, all you need is flour and water.
Hi Anna, Hope that you are well. Thanks for all of your wonderful posts. I usually make ‘Tarragon” butter. I absolutely LOVE Tarragon.
On a different subject, I was unable to download the latest magazine. Have never had that problem before. Is there a way that I can still get it?
Again, thaks
Hi Suzanne,
I love tarragon too, and I happen to have some fresh right now. I hadn’t actually thought of making tarragon butter with it but I think I’ll have to try it:) As for the magazine, I double checked and you’re definitely subscribed. Was it the April issue you were after?
If I had to sub a dried herb in place of one of the fresh herbs, how much would I use in place of 1/4c?
Hi Christine,
If using dried herbs, I would probably do about one tablespoon for every 1/4 cup of fresh herbs. If possible, using fresh herbs is preferable with this recipe as it preserves the flavour and texture of fresh herbs really nicely:) However dried herbs will still add flavour and will work in a pinch.